Local SEO vs. GBP Optimisation: Which Drives More Foot Traffic for Aussie Businesses?

• Local SEO builds long-term online visibility through website optimisation, local keywords, and backlinks. It’s ideal for businesses targeting multiple suburbs or wider areas.
• Google Business Profile (GBP) Optimisation delivers quicker results by enhancing your Google listing with updated details, photos, posts, and review management. Perfect for single-location businesses.

Key Stats:

• 97% of Australians search for local businesses online.
• 75% visit a store within 24 hours of a local search.
• GBP listings attract 400% more traffic than small business websites.

Quick Comparison:

For Aussie businesses, combining both strategies is the best way to boost foot traffic and sales. Start with GBP for quick wins, then invest in Local SEO for sustained growth.

Local SEO and GBP Basics

Local SEO Explained

Local SEO helps Australian businesses stand out by targeting local audiences through website optimisation. With over 85% of Australians relying on Google to find local products or services, it’s a must for driving foot traffic and online engagement.

Take Digital Spotlight‘s success stories as examples. They helped Twomey Dispute Lawyers increase qualified traffic by 320% in just two years. Another case? Enthusiast.com.au, a Sydney-based car insurance provider, saw an incredible 4,343% growth in organic traffic thanks to their efforts.

Here are some key components of a strong local SEO plan:

GBP Optimisation Explained

Think of your Google Business Profile (GBP) as your online storefront. For instance, a Brisbane café increased its foot traffic by 45% simply by keeping its profile updated and managing customer reviews effectively.

"Google My Business optimisation and ranking is one of the most important Ranking Factors in Google Local Search since Google is giving priority to user/customers experience… reviews in other words." – Maxstandout

The rise in "open now near me" searches – up by over 400% year-on-year – shows how critical it is to keep your GBP updated. Key steps for optimising your profile include:

• Ensuring accurate business hours and location details
• Uploading high-quality photos and videos
• Posting regularly about promotions and events
• Responding quickly to customer reviews
• Keeping service offerings up to date

This targeted approach boosts your visibility directly on Google, working hand-in-hand with broader SEO strategies.

Main Differences Between Both Methods

Local SEO and GBP optimisation share a common goal but take different routes to get there. Local SEO focuses on building a well-rounded online presence through website optimisation, keyword strategies, and link building.

On the other hand, GBP optimisation zeroes in on improving visibility specifically within Google’s ecosystem.

Here’s an example: a Sydney plumbing company doubled its call volume by integrating Google customer reviews into its website.

"By prioritising user experience in local searches, we’ve seen clients leapfrog competitors in terms of online visibility and engagement." – ProfileTree’s Web Development Team

Foot Traffic Results Comparison

Local SEO Results

Local SEO plays a key role in driving foot traffic across Australia. Research reveals that 97% of Australians search for local businesses online. Of those, 76% visit a business within 24 hours, and 28% make a purchase.

The impact of local SEO often depends on the industry. For example, Melbourne’s Advanced Skin & Cosmetic Tattoo saw its star rating climb from 4.2 to 4.9, which helped increase client trust and bookings.

However, while local SEO builds long-term visibility, Google Business Profile (GBP) optimisation offers faster, profile-driven results.

GBP Results

Optimising your GBP can significantly boost local visibility. GBP listings attract 400% more traffic than small business websites, with over half of all profiles receiving more than 1,000 views each month.

Visual content plays a huge role in GBP performance:

A great example is Newcastle’s Baird Real Estate. They saw a 340% increase in Google reviews after introducing automated review requests. This change led to more office visits and client consultations.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Here’s a quick comparison of Local SEO and GBP optimisation:

For instance, Melbourne’s Aston Legal Group combined both strategies to increase their visibility by 60%. These examples highlight how GBP delivers immediate results, while Perth SEO builds a lasting presence in the market.

Australian Business Examples

Melbourne Cafe Local SEO Results

Anh Anh Vietnamese Restaurant in Melbourne is a great example of how local SEO can boost foot traffic. By focusing on local SEO strategies – like using targeted local keywords and actively managing online reviews – the restaurant transformed from a quiet spot to a bustling one.

These efforts paid off significantly, with December 2023 becoming its busiest month since opening. A noticeable improvement in Google’s local pack visibility directly contributed to the increase in customer visits.

Sydney Shop GBP Results

While Melbourne highlights the long-term benefits of local SEO, the Sydney example focuses on how Google Business Profile (GBP) features can drive immediate customer engagement.

For Sydney businesses, keeping NAP (Name, Address, Phone) details accurate across platforms is critical for local search visibility. Regular updates and engaging with customer reviews also help maintain a strong presence in the local market.

Key Lessons Learned

These examples highlight practical steps for boosting local foot traffic. Here are the main takeaways:

• Consistency matters: Keeping business details consistent across all platforms builds trust with both search engines and potential customers.
• Engagement is crucial: Regular updates to your GBP, such as adding photos and posts, make your profile more appealing and can increase foot traffic.
• Review management is essential: Monitoring and responding to reviews strengthens credibility and fosters customer loyalty.

Both examples demonstrate that local SEO strategies build long-term visibility, while GBP optimisation delivers quick wins in customer discovery and engagement.

sbb-itb-c74901f

Picking Your Strategy

These two organic SEO strategies should always be combined for best results if you are a local business. They do have a few differences you need to understand:

Decision Points

Here’s how to decide between focusing on Local SEO or Google Business Profile (GBP):

When to Use Local SEO

Local SEO works best in these situations:

• Reaching multiple suburbs: Optimise your website with local keywords to attract searches from different areas.
• Building a strong online presence: Use localised landing pages and secure backlinks aimed at your target regions.
• Standing out in crowded markets: With the rise in "near me" searches, targeted content can help set your business apart.

When to Use GBP

Consider GBP if:

• You’re launching a new business: Verified GBP listings make businesses 2.7 times more likely to be seen as reputable.
• Visuals are key to sales: Listings with photos get 42% more requests for driving directions, which is perfect for cafes, shops, or salons.
• You need quick results: With 75% of local searchers visiting stores within 24 hours, features like direct messaging, posts, and reviews can drive immediate foot traffic.

Local SEO vs Traditional SEO & Google My Business

Performance Tracking

This section breaks down the key metrics and tools needed to monitor local SEO and Google Business Profile (GBP) performance, helping Aussie businesses attract more foot traffic.

Local SEO Metrics

Pay attention to these local SEO metrics: organic traffic, search rankings, conversion rates, and landing page performance. According to Google Analytics, local and organic searches drive 69% of website traffic.

Here’s what you should track:

• Organic traffic from specific suburbs
• Map pack and traditional search rankings
• Customer actions like phone calls, form submissions, and direction requests
• Conversion rates for location-specific landing pages

These metrics provide a solid foundation for assessing your local SEO efforts. Now, let’s see how GBP data fits into the picture.

GBP Performance Data

Insights from GBP reveal that verified businesses typically receive 66 direction requests and 50 phone calls each month.

These metrics highlight customer behaviour and preferences, giving you actionable insights to boost engagement.

Tracking Tools

Use these tools to monitor and optimise performance effectively:

Google Analytics

• Enable geo-targeting to focus on specific areas
• Set up conversion goals to measure success
• Use UTM parameters to track GBP profile traffic

Google Search Console

• Keep an eye on local keyword performance
• Analyse click-through rates
• Identify top-performing pages for specific locations

GBP Insights

Track customer interactions directly through your Google Business Profile, such as calls, clicks, and direction requests.

"Ignoring reviews results in a failure to serve and engage with your existing consumer base, win back customers who have left negative reviews, and benefit from the business intelligence gained when review sentiment is analysed."

Specialised Tools

• Birdeye: Manage and analyse customer reviews
• Local Falcon: Analyse map pack rankings and is our go to Geo Grid reporting tool!
• Citation tracking tools: Ensure NAP (Name, Address, Phone) consistency across platforms

With 98% of people using the internet to search for local businesses, these tools can help turn online data into actionable strategies to drive more customers through your doors.

Conclusion

Main Points Review

Local SEO and Google Business Profile (GBP) optimisation are powerful tools for increasing foot traffic to Australian businesses and go hand in hand.

With 97% of Australians using online searches to find local businesses and 76% visiting a business within 24 hours of their search, the benefits are undeniable.

These takeaways highlight clear opportunities for action.

Next Steps

The comparison above points to two key strategies:

• Quick Wins: Start with GBP optimisation, as demonstrated by Advanced Skin & Cosmetic Tattoo’s success story.
• Long-Term Results: Build a comprehensive Local SEO plan while keeping your GBP updated, as shown by Baird Real Estate’s effective approach.

"Most businesses are doing Google Posts all wrong. They treat their Google Business Profile like a social media profile, but it is NOT. GBP is the one platform that people visit with the intent to BUY, so lean into that." – Darren Shaw

Make it a priority to gather customer reviews and regularly update your GBP with relevant content. Since 90% of search traffic goes to page-one results, combining Local SEO with consistent GBP management is the best way to maximise visibility and drive more foot traffic.

Related posts

• Small Business SEO Guide: Essential Strategies for Growth
• Common SEO Problems and Solutions for Australian Businesses
• How To Use Google Business Profile Insights
• How To Write Location-Specific Blog Content